Adding co-founder post-incorporation: transfer existing shares or issue new?

I incorporated solo via Stripe Atlas (Delaware C-corp). Issued myself founder shares (all of it except for employee pool is in my name) at par value and filed 83(b). Now bringing on a co-founder and want to give them a significant equity stake.

What's the cleanest approach:

  1. Transfer portion of my existing shares to co-founder (gift or sale at par value)

  2. Surrender shares back to company (at no cost), then reissue to co-founder

  3. Issue new shares to co-founder (expanding total issued shares) to get the right equity split

Main concerns:

  • Tax implications for both parties (gift tax, capital gains, 83(b))

  • QSBS eligibility preservation

  • Proper vesting setup for co-founder

  • Investor optics

  • Paperwork involved (Less is preferable and self-serve via Carta is preferable compared to engaging an attorney besides for advice)

Company Context:

  • It's been 40ish days since I assigned the shares to myself, filed for 83(b) to now.

  • Completely is completely bootstrapped and FMV hasn't changed at all (pre-revenue) - no external investors.

Any guidance on the right structure appreciated. Thanks!



------------------------------
Mukil Kesavan
------------------------------